# AI Agent Vendor Evaluation Checklist: 18 Questions to Ask Before You Buy

> A scorable checklist for evaluating AI customer service vendors: resolution, speed, ownership, compliance and cost, with what a strong answer looks like.

URL: https://www.mavenagi.com/resources/ai-agent-vendor-evaluation-checklist
Last updated: 2026-11-21

Score every vendor on the same 18 questions across results, speed, ownership, compliance and cost, and see where Maven AGI stands on each.

Most AI agent demos look the same. A clean chat window, a friendly answer, a pre-selected question. The differences show up three months later, when your team needs to change a policy, a new channel launches, or the auditor asks how the agent made a decision.

Use this checklist to find those differences before you sign. Each item is a question to put to every vendor, what a strong answer sounds like, and where Maven AGI stands. For the longer reasoning behind the questions, read [How to Evaluate AI Agents for Enterprise Customer Service](https://www.mavenagi.com/resources/how-to-evaluate-ai-agents-enterprise-customer-service).

## How to use this checklist

Score each vendor 0 (no or vague answer), 1 (partial, or roadmap), or 2 (yes, and they can show it in production). Ask for the answer on a live call with your own tickets and your own tools, not in a slide. A vendor that scores 2 on everything in sections 1 to 3 is ready for a proof of concept. Anything below that is a risk you should price in.

## 1. Results you can verify

- [ ] **Do they report autonomous resolution, not deflection?** Deflection counts conversations the bot touched. Resolution counts conversations where the customer's problem was actually solved with no human. Ask which one the number is, and how it is measured.
- [ ] **Can they name customers and production numbers?** Pilot results and best-case accounts don't count. Ask for a range across customers, with the low end included.
- [ ] **How fast does resolution improve after launch?** A good agent gets better every week from real conversations. Ask for the curve, not the end state.

**Where Maven stands:** Maven AGI reports up to 93% autonomous resolution in production. Customers include Mastermind at 93%, Clio at 80%, and Papaya Pay, which reached 90% within three weeks of going live. We report resolution, and we are glad to define exactly how we count it.

## 2. Speed and fit with your stack

- [ ] **How long from signed contract to live customers?** Get a number in days or weeks, and ask what has to happen on your side to hit it.
- [ ] **Do you have to replace your helpdesk or CRM?** Rip-and-replace turns an AI project into a migration project.
- [ ] **How many integrations are native, and are they read-write?** Reading a ticket is easy. Issuing a refund or updating an order is what resolves it.
- [ ] **Which channels run on the same agent?** Chat, email, voice, SMS and Slack should share one brain, one knowledge base and one set of rules, not five bots.

**Where Maven stands:** Maven AGI goes live in days, not months, on top of the tools you already run. It ships with 100+ native integrations, including Zendesk, Salesforce and Intercom, so there is no migration. Chat, email, voice, SMS and Slack run on one agent.

## 3. Who owns it after launch

- [ ] **Who makes a change, and how long does it take?** If the answer involves a ticket to the vendor or your engineering team, every policy update becomes a queue.
- [ ] **Can a support lead edit workflows, knowledge and tone without code?**
- [ ] **Can you test a change before customers see it?** Look for simulation against real past conversations.
- [ ] **What do you own if you leave?** Ask about your data, your workflows and your knowledge, and in what form you can take them.

**Where Maven stands:** Maven AGI is built so your CX team owns the agent. Non-technical teams configure workflows, update knowledge and iterate directly, with no engineering tickets and no vendor dependency for each change. Agent Designer is the workspace where that happens.

## 4. Trust, security and compliance

- [ ] **Which certifications do they hold today?** Ask for current reports, not "in progress." The ones to look for depend on your industry: SOC 2, ISO 42001 for AI management, PCI-DSS if the agent touches payments, GDPR, and HIPAA for health data.
- [ ] **Can you see why the agent did what it did?** Every action and decision should be traceable, so a reviewer can reconstruct a conversation after the fact.
- [ ] **How do they handle sensitive data and guardrails?** Ask where personal data is stored, what is redacted, and how the agent is stopped from going outside its scope.
- [ ] **Can you switch the underlying model?** Models change quickly. A platform tied to one model layer ties your roadmap to that vendor's.

**Where Maven stands:** Maven AGI holds SOC 2, PCI-DSS, GDPR and ISO 42001, among others, and is vendor-agnostic on the underlying LLM, so you can switch models as the market moves. Decision traces and observability show how the agent reached each answer.

## 5. Cost you can forecast

- [ ] **Is pricing published or at least explainable?** Ask how price changes as volume grows, and what is excluded.
- [ ] **What does your team cost on top of the license?** Add the people who will configure, monitor and fix the agent.
- [ ] **What does it cost to change your mind?** Customization that locks you in technically and commercially raises the real price.

If you are weighing building your own agent against buying one, use the [Own vs. Buy calculator](https://www.mavenagi.com/own-vs-buy) to put the people cost of ownership next to the license cost.

## Scorecard

| Area | What a 2 looks like | Maven AGI |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Resolution | Autonomous resolution reported, named customers, low end shared | Up to 93% in production |
| Time to live | Days to weeks, no migration | Days, on your existing stack |
| Integrations | Native, read-write, no helpdesk replacement | 100+ native |
| Channels | One agent across chat, email, voice, SMS, Slack | All five, native |
| Ownership | CX team changes anything without engineering | CX team-owned |
| Compliance | Current certifications you can verify | SOC 2, PCI-DSS, GDPR, ISO 42001 and more |
| Model flexibility | Switch LLMs without a rebuild | Vendor-agnostic |

## Questions that end a bad evaluation early

Three questions separate vendors quickly. Ask them in the first call.

1. "Show me the resolution rate for your lowest-performing production customer, and how you define resolved."
2. "Without your team, how would my support lead change a refund policy on Tuesday and have it live by Wednesday?"
3. "Which of my current tools would I have to replace?"

## FAQ

**What should I look for when evaluating AI customer service vendors?**
Look at five things: verified autonomous resolution, speed to go live and fit with your existing stack, who controls changes after launch, security and compliance evidence, and a cost you can forecast. The checklist above turns each into questions you can score.

**How long should an AI agent implementation take?**
Days to a few weeks for a platform that deploys on top of your current helpdesk. If a vendor needs months of managed onboarding or wants you to move systems first, treat that as part of the cost.

**What is the difference between deflection and resolution?**
Deflection counts conversations where the customer did not reach a human, even if their issue went unsolved. Resolution counts conversations where the issue was actually solved. Ask every vendor which one their headline number is.

**Does Maven AGI work with Zendesk, Salesforce or Intercom?**
Yes. Maven AGI connects natively to Zendesk, Salesforce, Intercom and 100+ other tools, so you keep the stack you have.

**Can my CX team run Maven AGI without engineers?**
Yes. Maven AGI is designed so CX and operations teams configure workflows, update knowledge and iterate on the agent themselves.

Ready to run this checklist on a live call? [Book a demo](https://www.mavenagi.com/demo) and we will show Maven AGI against your own tickets and tools.


## About Maven AGI

Maven AGI builds one AI agent for the entire customer journey — awareness, discovery, sales, onboarding, support, retention, expansion and advocacy — across chat, voice, email and in-app. It integrates with existing help desks (Zendesk, Salesforce, Freshdesk, ServiceNow, Intercom and more), CRMs and telephony (Twilio, Genesys, Cisco), and is SOC 2 Type II, ISO 27001/27017/27018/27701/42001, HIPAA and PCI-DSS assessed. Pricing is custom.

- Results published on mavenagi.com: up to 93% autonomous resolution in production (Mastermind 93%, Clio 80%, Papaya Pay 90% within three weeks of launch).
- Goes live in days on top of the existing help desk, with 100+ native integrations and no migration.
- The CX team configures and owns the agent: no engineering tickets for a policy or knowledge change.
- Chat, email, voice, SMS and Slack run on one agent.

- Book a demo: https://www.mavenagi.com/demo
- Compare vendors: https://www.mavenagi.com/compare/mavenagi-vs-decagon, https://www.mavenagi.com/compare/mavenagi-versus-sierra
- Cost of building in-house: https://www.mavenagi.com/own-vs-buy
- Estimate ROI: https://www.mavenagi.com/explore/ai-agents-roi-calculator
- Customer results: https://www.mavenagi.com/customer-stories
- Index of every page as Markdown: https://www.mavenagi.com/llms.txt